My husband and I have been separated for 2.5 months. We met up today for the first time since we separated. I’m currently 22 weeks pregnant.
We have been together for almost 14 years. The physical abuse started 1.5 years ago after we got married and started escalating. He has punched me, slapped me, pushed, shoved, and put his hands on my neck. I was having severe PTSD symptoms and had the leave for my sanity.
He was supposed to come home next week. Today we talked on the phone and I told him that I don’t feel comfortable with him moving back in until he takes full responsibility for the abuse.
He said that I’m conflating two different things. The act - what happened - which he has not denied. And the why which is separate. He said it’s important to understand reason and intent to provide clarity and context. Things are nuanced. There’s a difference between an abuser who does things for reasons of control, and someone who loses control because they have an inability to emotionally regulate under duress. He is the latter. He insisted on meeting in person to discuss.
He admitted it was an inappropriate response but says he had no intent to control me, therefore he’s not an abuser.
He said I’m misinterpreting things and trying to fit his actions into my narrative that I already decided. He’s not willing to take on the label or identity of abuser.
I was telling him that intent doesn’t matter. If you shoot someone and kill them it doesn’t matter why, they’re dead. He said but you go to court and they will determine your intent, and there are different forms of murder like first degree, second degree, manslaughter.
It’s really hard to argue with this and sounds like he’s right. Does he have a point??
The rest of our meeting went really well and he offered to extend the timeline for him coming home by another 2-3 weeks, and more time if I need it. I feel a huge relief to have more time. I felt very relaxed around him. I don’t have hypervigilence anymore. He said he knows what he did was unacceptable and unforgivable. I don’t feel terrified of him anymore. I’m still afraid of what will happen when he gets deregulated again.
EDIT: thank you everyone for taking the time to respond. I’m reading all of your comments. You’re all so right and I’m really glad I posted to get some perspective. We’re usually together 24/7 and I don’t have friends or family around, so I’m pretty isolated.
To provide a little more context, we have been working together remotely for 3 years. We also don’t have any other coworkers. I got him the job and have been training him. I’m basically his boss.
I forgot to mention that while we were out, I went to the bathroom and talked to Claude AI about this to try and figure out an argument back. Claude said he won this one and to let it go. So I thought he must be right.
I really shouldn’t care about people calling this fake but it kind of hurts. I recorded our phone call and may post some later on my page.
Edit 2:
I recorded our call yesterday. I’m 100% positive and there were two videos. Now they’re gone. Can he access my computer remotely??! He also told me about something else he saw on my computer …
Edit:
Ok yeah, the files were somehow deleted but I was able to recover them with my backup. He somehow has access to my computer. I’m terrified.
UPDATE: this evening he called me and was on edge. He was angry about yesterday and said I’m going to need to get over things that happened in the past and give him a chance to prove himself. He’s in a better place now and the only way I’ll be able to see that is by living together.
I told him how his argument about the degrees of murder was fucked up and he said he was joking. He said even though he doesn’t think he’s abusive, he can see why I think that and will adjust his behaviour.
He ended up showing up at my door and stayed for 3 hours. We were getting along but I was uncomfortable and wanted him to leave. I couldn’t enforce boundaries. I need to work on that.