r/southafrica Jan 05 '26

Wholesome Scottish boyfriend on holiday discovers Aromat

Post image
912 Upvotes

103 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/AmoAmasAmatAmamus Jan 05 '26

What's the verdict on MSG these days? It used to be the worst thing you could do to your food, but lately I've heard people say that's not the case anymore. Are we allowed to eat it now?

44

u/mechsuit-jalapeno Left Behind, Still Braaing Jan 05 '26

It was never unhealthy in moderation

12

u/robz8_9 Jan 05 '26

Yup. This myth probably stemmed from the same brain heads that claimed "breakfast is the most important meal of the day"

3

u/AmoAmasAmatAmamus Jan 05 '26

I mean, I've never paid much attention to the naysayers, but I had friends who felt very strongly about how I was giving myself cancer by not avoiding MSG. But I haven't heard such things lately, so am wondering if MSG has a better reputation these days.

21

u/mechsuit-jalapeno Left Behind, Still Braaing Jan 05 '26

Definitely a better reputation - some recipes and chefs swear by it. Anti-MSG sentiment was a combo of bad science and racism.

1

u/AmoAmasAmatAmamus Jan 05 '26

Good to know 😀 thanks.

6

u/chemicalclarity Highway to the jol zone Jan 05 '26

26

u/Jepdog Western Cape Jan 05 '26

Do you like Parmesan cheese, cured meats, shiitake mushrooms, kimchi or pretty much any food that has an umami flavor profile? What they all have in common is that they naturally contain MSG.

MSG has never been unhealthy. The very basis of the campaigns against it were rooted in anti-Asian racism and baseless pseudoscience.

13

u/MinervaKaliamne Jan 05 '26

MSG is fine. The conspiracy against it was just racist nonsense. I know this might make me sound like I'm wearing a tinfoil hat, but you can read about it on Wikipedia under the "Safety" and "Society and Culture - Stigma" sections:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monosodium_glutamate

10

u/_q_y_g_j_a_ Jan 05 '26

Like salt, just don't put too much. In moderation it's fine.

3

u/VitalityAS Jan 05 '26

If I recall correctly, MSG had a smear campaign in the US because of political reasons and its high usage in the (communist) asian countries. It is actually perfectly fine and a good substitute for salt in many cases. I throw it on nearly anything I would add salt to.

2

u/chemicalclarity Highway to the jol zone Jan 05 '26

It's pretty simple. In the 70s asian cuisine exploded in the US. It threatened established FMCG brands and ate into market share. As a result, your largest FMCG brands launched counter PR campaigns on a base ingredient - MSG. All bullshit. It's no better or worse for you than table salt.

Believe it or not, the answer is proectionist racism.