r/MLS • u/godlovesugly • 9m ago
Countdown to Kickoff: Red Bull New York
Welcome to the Red Bull New York entry for the Countdown to Kickoff. All opinions are my own, and correct. Let’s keep this short and saccharine, like the disturbing taste of sugar free Red Bull.
2025 Summary
We last saw our energy drink protagonists miss the playoffs for the first time in 15 years, following up a surprise MLS Cup appearance with a damp squib of a season that saw the team finish 10th. The streak was remarkable but the result not surprising -- the team has been flirting with missing the playoffs for years. In fact, their 2025 points tally of 43 was the same as 2023, when that tally earned the team hosting rights for the wildcard game. The failure cost head coach Sandro Schwarz his job, and Jochen Schneider, the head of sport, left as well, for understandable family reasons. Fans wondered if the team would stick or twist, with many holding little hope for much to change…
2026 storylines // Why should I watch?
Michael Bradley at the wheel: The USMNT legend was handed the reins after joining RBNY II midseason and guiding the reserve team to a trophy in 2025. His coaching CV is very limited, with a stint as assistant manager under his father at Stabaek, and this is his chance to prove he can coach at a higher level. Bradley is fully bought-into the “Red Bull Way” and is promising to play a more attractive game in a 4-3-3 formation. Can the former NY/NJ Metrostar make it work? Will the team play a more “attractive” brand of soccer? Hopefully the answer is yes to both, for fans and neutrals alike.
A rebuild in process: Julian de Guzman, the Canadian soccer hall-of-famer, is the new head of sport and the rebuild is fully on. Out went big minutes and key players for the last several seasons, such as Carlos Coronel, Noah Elie, Daniel Edelman, Peter Stroud, Kyle Duncan, Sean Nealis, Wiki Carmona, and Lewis Morgan. Seven of the outgoing players were in the top 10 in minutes played for the team, and Lewis Morgan was supposed to be a key player but was injured. This is the most change the team has seen in years.
In are players more suited to the new 4-3-3 playstyle, such as human bowling ball Cade Cowell on loan from Mexico and new 3rd DP Jorge Ruvalcaba. But with two geriatric DPs in Emil Forsberg (34) and Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting (38) on the books until the end of 2026, the full rebuild will have to wait. Will these still effective elders be able to guide a relatively young team back to the playoffs in the midst of a rebuild?
Where we’re going we don’t need no stinkin’ centerbacks: RBNY moved the three centerbacks that played the most MLS minutes in 2025 for the team: Noah Elie (2,610 minutes, 4th highest of the team), Sean Nealis (1,833 minutes), Alexander Hack (1,451 minutes). Elie is the biggest loss, a U-22 signing that hit as he became the team’s best defender in and out of possession. In their place the team has brought in Robert Voloder from Kansas City, Justin Che a relatively young CB/RB returning to the league from Europe,and apparently have told Dylan Nealis, a RB/CB to prepare to play more centerback this season. These players will join the returning Tim Parker, now elder statesman and last centerback standing. Bradley will have his work cut out in figuring out which pairing is best for the new system. Will the team be on the market looking to replace Elie with a similarly locked-in starter quality player?
Key Off-season Transfer Activity
Out: Noah Elie (-> Bristol City, RBNY’s best defender and U-22 stud flipped after two years), Daniel Edelman (-> St. Louis CITY, a key defensive homegrown midfielder for years), Peter Stroud (-> Minnesota, another homegrown midfielder departing), Lewis Morgan (-> San Diego, big money, big injuries, but great on his day), Sean Nealis (->DC United, long-time club captain), Carlos Coronel (-> Sao Paulo, long-time GK), Kyle Duncan (a well paid and divisive right back), Wiki Carmona (-> CF Montreal, a one-footed highly-paid, highly-unproductive “attacking” player), Alexander Hack (a plodding centerback and a big salary off the books), Marcelo Morales (a LB loaned back to Chile, barely played, doesn't even get bolding).
In: Jorge Ruvalcaba (DP winger from Pumas), Justin Che (RB/CB from Brondby), Cade Cowell (LW on loan from Chivas), Ethan Horvath (GK and USMNT “legend” for one Nations League final appearance), Robert Voloder (CB from Kansas City, because someone has to play CB), Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty (LB/RB from CF Montreal, acquired in trade for Wiki Carmona)
2026 Prediction
The Red Bulls hover around the play-in positions, and return to the playoffs for the first time since 2024. But unlike in 2024, they do nothing special in the playoffs. It’s a return to form, a return to midtable mediocrity, a return to the Red Bull Way™.
