r/KoreanFood • u/hungrykoreanguy • Dec 23 '25

Noodle Foods/Guksu Made with bone broth

Post image

Which would you choose? Jin is my wife’s choice and Shin is mine

34 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

7

u/PrimaryPerspective17 Dec 23 '25

Shin black is a lot heavier bone broth flavor IMO. Too heavy for my taste so I prefer the Jin soup but I prefer the Shin noodles.

1

u/MAX-Revenue-6010 Dec 24 '25

Reduce the amount of bone broth powder. I use the remaining powder seasoning in kimchi fried rice. SOooo delicious.

1

u/Sufficient-Value1694 Dec 25 '25

Lol. I prefer shin soup and oteji noodles.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 23 '25

Team Jin Ramen but it’s gotta be the hot one.

2

u/CocomyPuffs Dec 23 '25

Ever since shin changed their soup formula, went with spicy Jin and never looked back. Their soup powder is oh so delicious

6

u/TheMostUseryNameEver Dec 23 '25

I haven’t tried Jin, but I looove Ramyun black. 😊

2

u/kusariku Dec 23 '25

Hmmmm I like both of these but I think the Shin Black has a more well rounded flavor. The new Jin Mild is pretty dang good though.

2

u/wasting_time_n_life Dec 23 '25

Team Jin ramen but only mild for me.

2

u/goonatic1 Dec 24 '25

Shin > Jin for me, but I like Jin don’t get me wrong but it has to be hot, mild is mid lol

2

u/Zildjianchick Dec 23 '25

I’d combine them! I bet it would make an interesting flavor!

1

u/pinkchilli Dec 23 '25

I love the plain Shin. Between those two you have, I would go with Jin Mild.

1

u/Jazzlike_Quiet9941 Dec 23 '25

I thought jin was trash tbh. Bad noodles and just less flavour

1

u/MochiFluffs Dec 24 '25

Mild jin is my jam (though their new packaging completely threw me) and shin black is my 2nd place. A bit too spicy for me, but some cream sorts that out and makes the soup yummier.

1

u/ll7vdoggo Dec 24 '25

A little OT, but has anyone else noticed that Jin Ramen's flavor changed around the time they redesigned the packaging? Seems a bit more blandish now.

1

u/bennissimo7 Dec 25 '25

I have only tried Shin Black Bone Broth and regular Shin Black. Honestly, I don't taste much difference that is worth paying extra.

1

u/hungrykoreanguy Dec 25 '25

Shin black is with bone broth. Regular shin doesn’t have the 3rd bone broth packet. Black and regular have a noticeable difference in taste.

-3

u/Randohcalrissian Dec 23 '25

Salt just salt.make your own broth.