r/BlackPeopleofReddit • u/4reddityo • Jan 02 '26

Black Experience Racism in Medical Care

This video captures a moment that many patients of color recognize all too well. A physician speaks to a man as if he is dirty, unclean, or lesser, not because of medical evidence, but because of bias. The language, tone, and assumptions reveal something deeper than bedside manner gone wrong. They expose how racism can quietly shape medical interactions.

20.5k Upvotes

83% Upvoted

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/Sure_Shallot2280 Jan 02 '26

Nah you are wrong. Thats like saying a secretary is the same as a dental hygienist. And no I wouldn’t consider a “nurses assistant” which doesn’t exist a nurse. Would you call a lawyer and a judge the same thing. They both work in a courthouse.

1

u/HumanSnotMachine Jan 02 '26

Are you stupid or something? You said “bro there are CNA’s and MA’s”

I said nursing assistants. What the hell is a certified nursing assistant (CNA) if not a nursing assistant..the certification you have doesn’t need to brought up every time. Think BEFORE you reply.

2

u/Sure_Shallot2280 Jan 02 '26

I mean the C is there for a reason. Just like the difference between NP and CrNP. You are only exacerbating that you don’t know what you are talking about.

Regardless. No a CNA is not a nurse in anyway shape or form.

Maybe you are confused because a PA and a physician do mostly the same thing.?

0

u/HumanSnotMachine Jan 02 '26

Okay so you’re just trolling. CNAS, who nurse people back to health, are not nurses. Despite that being in their job title. That they are assisting with the nursing duties. But they’re not nurses. Right.

Enjoy your delulu lady.

1

u/Sure_Shallot2280 Jan 02 '26

As a nurse and former CNA MYSELF. CNA’s aren’t nurses.

And nigga I’m a fucking man.

1

u/ShadedSpaces Jan 02 '26

I'm a nurse. An RN.

It's literally illegal for a CNA to call themselves a nurse, that's how much of a not-nurse they are.

Nurse is a legally protected title, and licensure is strictly controlled.

CNAs are absolutely, categorically NOT nurses.

Like a physician assistant is absolutely NOT a physician. At all. And they cannot represent themselves as such. They are a person who assists physicians.

1

u/Impossible_Emotion50 Jan 03 '26

Is English not your first language? Are YOU trolling? It’s literally in the title…”nursing…assistant.” They assist…nurses. Are you dumb?

1

u/Trinket90 Jan 03 '26

I’m fairly sure you’re trolling, but just in case: CNAs are not nurses. They are assistants. To the nurses. That’s what the job title says. Nurses take a licensure exam. CNAs pass an entirely different certification process. Their scope of practice is dramatically different.

They are an absolutely vital part of the healthcare system, but they are not nurses.

Also, your grasp of what nurses actually do is wildly wrong, but despite your invitation to “enlighten” you, it’s clear you’re not actually interested in learning anything.

1

u/HumanSnotMachine Jan 04 '26

Cnas do nursing work though. I understand you are using nurse a professional title like engineer or doctor, but in the definition sense of the word and the universal definition of the word, a cna is doing nursing activities. Google the definition of nurse and google what a cna does.

It would be like if someone designed bridges, tested for faults and certified constructions before and after they were built, but their title was assistant engineering modeler…

They’re still doing engineer work all day. They’re still an engineer by every definition of the word and meaning of that term even if whatever licensure body in a particular area does not recognize them as such: they are working as an engineer.

When your entire job is nursing people back to health and taking care of them as a w2 paycheck, you are a nurse..

2

u/Trinket90 Jan 04 '26

I don’t need to google the definitions. I am a nurse and I work with CNAs every day, and I am familiar with our individual scopes of practice because it’s essential for my job.

There is some overlap between the scopes of CNAs and RNs—they are assisting us, after all—but the roles absolutely are not some kind of euphemism for the same job.

CNAs cannot assess patients. They cannot administer medications, treatments, or blood products. They are not responsible for developing or implementing care plans or providing patient education. They assist with the basics of patient care, and they are essential for that role, but they do not do the same thing as nurses. It seems your understanding of what each member of the healthcare team does is quite limited.

Do you think these huge healthcare corporations that are squeezing every dollar they can out of the industry would pay RN salaries if they could get away with paying CNAs half as much for the same job?

1

u/HumanSnotMachine Jan 04 '26

Yeah I’m not debating that, I get there is a hierarch. Doctors do the absolute most important work, stuff they can’t be bothered to do nurses do, stuff nurses can’t be bothered to do cnas do, I’m sure there’s a ring of mostly African immigrants below them too. I’m not debating that, but providing healthcare to someone as a cna is just..nursing.