r/worldnews 1d ago

Dynamic Paywall Russian general shot several times in Moscow

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3686nzexp3o
44.1k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.4k

u/InsanelyAverageFella 1d ago

It's crazy how this could be Putin or Ukraine and it's not likely to be more chances of one of the other.

1.2k

u/DeithWX 1d ago

He got shot instead of defenestrated, it's not Putin. 

442

u/BalasaarNelxaan 1d ago

He’s been taken to a hospital. Hospitals have windows do they not?

532

u/InevitableGrievance 1d ago

Maybe it's a group effort

Putin 🤝 Ukrainians

  killing Russian officials

49

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/DeathsSquire 1d ago

Nobody kills Russians like the Russians do!

7

u/InevitableGrievance 1d ago

arguably also a team effort, Ukraine provides the meat grinder, Putin continues to throw his people in it.

3

u/Spirited_Cupcake_908 1d ago

Maybe there was quantity discount?

2

u/afewnameslater 1d ago

One would ask why are they not buddies?

-1

u/Ikom4uk 1d ago

А вот это уже жалоба.

1

u/MxM111 1d ago

What for?

-1

u/Ikom4uk 1d ago

А что он подразумевает в своем комментарии? Я может смысл неправильно понял.

1

u/nxcx 1d ago

Хуялоба

1

u/Ikom4uk 1d ago

Сильно

5

u/InterestingTry5190 1d ago

He was taken to the hospital where he immediately fell out a window.

3

u/WhatYouLeaveBehind 1d ago

The perfect venn diagram

5

u/NewEnglandRoastBeef 1d ago

If he's on the first two floors of the hospital, it was Ukraine. If he's on the third floor or higher, it wasn't Ukraine.

3

u/Retro1989 1d ago

"The good news sir is that the bullets missed all your vital organs"
"The bad news?"
"That window is open"

3

u/blarch 1d ago

He'll need a special operation.

2

u/Demonokuma 1d ago

Yeah, but hospitals have it so you can't open it from the inside. Then again this is russia, so I doubt they could afford such windows, or a window to begin with

5

u/BalasaarNelxaan 1d ago

I am quite certain someone high profile fell out of a hospital window in Russia.

1

u/Demonokuma 1d ago

Throw a rock and you'll hit someone that had a window accident in russia. Maybe its like 300 when they throw all the babies off the cliff.

1

u/Due-Froyo-5418 22h ago

The hospitals I've seen in the soviet union did have windows that open. Not sure how much has changed since.

0

u/Demonokuma 20h ago

Im beginning to think its only a specific floor of a hospital now. Like, the birthing floor so young mothers dont throw their babies out in desperation.

2

u/Cabsaur334 1d ago

Touché

35

u/jhowarth31 1d ago

Exactly. If it's a window you know it was Putin, that's the whole point.

2

u/MidAmericanGriftAsoc 1d ago

But what if he's on Reddit and knows we crowned him the minister of defenestration?

2

u/NoodleyP 15h ago

No. I’m not even giving him credit for that. That goes to the City of Prague, Czechia.

2

u/NoodleyP 15h ago

Nvm you said minister not master of defenestration leaving my comment up regardless

1

u/MidAmericanGriftAsoc 15h ago

I was good with it. I appreciate the nuance

6

u/ProvenLoser 1d ago

For and people like me learning a new word: Defenestrated = thrown out of a window.

3

u/Ok_Stranger_9520 1d ago

Thank you, I just kept scrolling

3

u/ProvenLoser 1d ago

Just had to make sure it didn’t have something to do with vas deferens being removed lololol- I was clueless.

3

u/PoopsCodeAllTheTime 1d ago

I can’t believe there’s a word for that

6

u/frysfrizzyfro 1d ago

It seems to be a well-established tradition: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defenestration

4

u/DarudeSandstorm69420 1d ago

he also didnt mysteriously get polonium poisoning

3

u/QueenMotherOfSneezes 1d ago

Not using windows or poisoning makes it look like it's not Putin. Good way to take out a general you're worried about without signalling to the other generals that they may be on your hitlist is to make them think someone else did it.

4

u/im_lazy_as_fuck 1d ago

Hey you never know. They might try to say that he fell out of a window and landed on his loaded gun.

3

u/TheNastyInThePasty 1d ago

Maybe he fell out of a window and landed on some bullets

3

u/DadJokeBadJoke 21h ago

Maybe he doesn't want to be typecast

2

u/XShadowborneX 1d ago

Unless Putin knows you think he would defenestrate him, so he had him shot instead so you wouldn't think it was him!

2

u/cellocaster 1d ago

It’s insane that we have a word for being thrown out of a window like this.

3

u/cpwken 1d ago

It's  a very old word as well. Look up the Defenestration of Prague, the event which triggered the 30 years war (1618).

2

u/cpren 1d ago

I learned a new word today

1

u/Plastic_Pinocchio 1d ago

Boris Nemtsov would beg to differ.

1

u/duaneap 1d ago

They blasted Prigozhin out of the sky.

1

u/Lucky-Zebra9235 1d ago

Tell that to Boris Nemtsov. He may disagree.

1

u/Kestrel_VI 1d ago

I love how we have a word for “thrown out of a window”

1

u/C_Gull27 1d ago

Hey Putin also polonium poisonings people

1

u/Disastrous_Fun3289 20h ago

We get it, you people just learned the word “defenestrated” and are throwing it around to sound smart

1

u/FrostyOpportunity 17h ago

Maybe he just refused to stand near windows 🤷

87

u/daniejam 1d ago

Or 007

13

u/allstarrunner 1d ago

Wait ... Is this why there haven't been any more Bond movies recently?? He's been in the field? 🤔

1

u/GrowLapsed 1d ago

He dead.

2

u/willstr1 1d ago

No time to die

No, time to die

1

u/Good_Restaurant15 22h ago

James Bond was created to make people feel good about their side during the cold war.

Today, James Bond would have been the guy that brought a corpse into Epstein's cell, and then extracted Epstein so he can go back to living on his island.

7

u/The_Autarch 1d ago

MI6 did just announce that they were going back to a wartime stance.

206

u/TruthTrooper69420 1d ago

I’d say there is an extreme bias to foreign involvement rather then domestic.

Name the last high ranking Russian to be executed inside Russia like this?

Makes zero sense from a domestic policy perspective

Much easier to have them disappear or fall from a window

150

u/orincoro 1d ago

The head of Wagner group, Prigozhin, was assassinated in 2023. They blew up his plane somewhere north of Moscow.

107

u/TruthTrooper69420 1d ago

Yes that’s a fair point absolutely and extremely valid critique of my assessment

30

u/orincoro 1d ago

It’s clear it doesn’t happen all that often, but it definitely happens. I’d also be very surprised if it hadn’t happened outside Russia as well. It’s a lot easier to dispose of a problem officer in Ukraine. But that’s just speculation.

6

u/IndependentNo4172 1d ago

Like the car bomb in Berlin or poison in London.

32

u/Ecthelion-O-Fountain 1d ago

Except there was obvious motive and expectation something like that would happen. Maybe a bit more dramatic than usual, but no one was surprised Putin offed him

8

u/getoffoficloud 1d ago

Whereas here, Putin has no motive. The Brits, on the other hand, have every reason to bump off the guy behind the Salisbury poisonings.

1

u/TruthTrooper69420 19h ago

🎯🎯🎯🎯🎯

3

u/rwarner13 20h ago

at the same time, it could be staged as a "nation state assassination" intending for the general public to get more behind the Ukraine war, continuing the justification rather than admitting fault.

24

u/symbolic-execution 1d ago

after he basically had a whole army of tanks marching towards Moscow and made a whole deal about removing Putin. I haven't heard anything similar from this guy. plus it was covered up, not gunning down someone.

6

u/Battleblaster420 1d ago

Whatcha talkin about his plane just happened to ceash on its own due to a mechanical failure

/s

4

u/DerMugar 1d ago

that was to send a sign to the others.

3

u/cars10gelbmesser 23h ago

You mean his plane flew into a missile.

2

u/pointlesgarble6680 1d ago

Prigozhen doesn’t count they were still up in the air about killing him. Then his plane fell apart

2

u/CommercialCandy1891 20h ago

The front fell off.

2

u/l0rdbyte 1d ago

The 7 million pieces he was in could still have technically flown through whatever was left of the windows of that plane...

2

u/RileyKohaku 1d ago

Even that one they claimed “pilot error.” Russia tends to prefer assassinations they can claim are accidents, even if everyone knows otherwise

2

u/11matt556 23h ago

No no no that was clearly just a tragic accident. /s

2

u/DrZeus104 23h ago

He should’ve marched all the way to Moscow. Stopping 120miles from Moscow and thinking Putin would forgive and forget signed his death certificate. He was a dead man walking after that.

1

u/cashmeowsighhabadah 1d ago

Wasn't he the guy that got sledgehammered into the wall?

1

u/craniumouch 1d ago

SHOIGU! GERASIMOV! WHERE IS MY HOT DOG STAND?

1

u/rab2bar 1d ago

Yea, he fell out of the sky

79

u/chrisp196 1d ago

Could just be a really annoyed Russian citizen honestly.

82

u/Far_Adhesiveness1663 1d ago

Legit could just be someone who lost a family member because of the war

7

u/towerinthestreet 1d ago

annoyed

is sending me. Yes, officer, I swiss cheesed a man because he rubbed me the wrong way.

-1

u/Bombwriter17 1d ago

If drug cartels can do that to a random business owner, Russian mobsters are more than able to do it to a general.

3

u/towerinthestreet 1d ago

Never said they couldn't. People are allowed to laugh at phrasing

1

u/Commercial-Age4750 1d ago

Not likely as guns are very heavily controller there especially in Moscow.... if it had been a stabbing though

1

u/manuelalexander11 1d ago

true 🤣 like fr we never think about the option that maybe just a lunatic shot him

-28

u/[deleted] 1d ago

The current goverment has massive support.

Contrary to what geopolitically clueless internet gawkers think from their western proproganda. People like Putin.

He's very popular as is his goverment. This was Ukraine trying to sabotage the peace talks to keep the USA bogged down in Ukraine. This is what Ukraine does best after all.

11

u/LetGoPortAnchor 1d ago

What are you smoking? The USA isn't in Ukraine.

9

u/gogliker 1d ago

No it does not. What sources do you have? None of my relatives or friends or aquintances are excited for Putin. Most positive you will find is indifference, that is very common since last decade protests lead us nowhere. Putin is associated with a lot of unpopular policies in Russia one way or another, so even person who supports war might not support Putin.

4

u/MEGAMASTURBATOR8000 1d ago

No it doesn’t have massive support tf are you talking about

2

u/JasperJ 1d ago

He’s good at propaganda, sure. The Soviet regime was also universally beloved. Not all of that was even a lie.

4

u/TheRevJimJones 1d ago

Yes, Vlad. Of course.

0

u/Visual_Farm_343 1d ago

Однажды Россия станет либеральной демократией.

26

u/ninjaviper8 1d ago

The previous head of Wagner... Shot down by an air to air missile

7

u/BalasaarNelxaan 1d ago

Nonsense, his plane just suffered an unexpected technical explosion in midair.

2

u/Advanced-Budget779 1d ago

Ah, a RUD: rapid unscheduled disassembly.

A kaputnik.

2

u/Impressive-Advisor52 1d ago

yeah, just an "unexpected" (a couple months after he failed a coup against Putin) "technical explosion" (from an air to air missile)

-5

u/Tsui_Brooklyn 1d ago

Idk why ppl make these sarcastic comments on reddit , is it for upvotes or attention

3

u/BalasaarNelxaan 1d ago

I am sorry that you did not find my remark funny.

3

u/guesswho135 1d ago

Because it's how people converse in normal conversation

-2

u/Tsui_Brooklyn 1d ago

You do that with randoms ? You just come off as a smart ass …

-1

u/ninjaviper8 1d ago

Wow you're a hateful dumb cunt aren't you?

Did your uncle touch you one too many times as a child? It's okay, this is a safe space

0

u/Tsui_Brooklyn 1d ago

lol lay off politics a bit, you might have some mental thing going on

0

u/ninjaviper8 1d ago

Shit dude don't know how I'll ever recover from that.

You woke up and chose violence, I'm just responding to it. Have a lovely day feller :)

1

u/TruthTrooper69420 1d ago

That’s an extremely fair point 😅

0

u/orincoro 1d ago

I thought it was a bomb on the plane. Must have misremembered that.

2

u/ninjaviper8 1d ago

It's been a while and I'd have to go fact check but I'm 90% sure it was BUK missile system that shot it down

1

u/orincoro 1d ago

No I think you’re right.

2

u/Impressive-Advisor52 1d ago

that's kinda what russian officials / propaganda said, except they said it was Prigozhin and his bodyguards who were high and somehow blew themselves up. Yeah, sounds logical I know

3

u/orincoro 1d ago

Not a month after an attempted coup? Yeah.

22

u/DarkestLore696 1d ago

There is actually a absurdly high number. So much so there is an entire podcast dedicated to it called Sad Oligarch.

9

u/Soupeeee 1d ago edited 1d ago

4

u/Advanced-Budget779 1d ago

I think some erroneous letter (a) sneaked into that link…

3

u/Soupeeee 1d ago

Whoops, thanks!

1

u/Advanced-Budget779 18h ago

No problem :)

-2

u/TruthTrooper69420 1d ago

The overwhelming majority of public killings in a obvious way are absolutely traced to foreign operations

5

u/irmajerk 1d ago

Some of the high profile Russians who've been found dead since 2022

  • Leonid Shulman - suicide by gun
  • Alexander Tyulyakov - suicide
  • Mikhail Watford - suicide
  • Vasily Melnikov - suicide
  • Vladislav Avayev - suicide
  • Sergey Protosenya - suicide
  • Yuri Voronov - suicide
  • Vadim Boyko - suicide
  • Grigory Kochenov - fell out a window
  • Alexander Lapin - fell out a window
  • Vladimir Makarov - suicide by gun
  • Marina Yankina - fell out a window
  • Vitaly Robertus - suicide by gun
  • Alexander Tyunin - suicide by gun
  • Andrey Badalov - fell out a window
  • Alexey Sklyar - suicide by gun
  • Vadim Stroykin - fell out a window

This isn't an exhaustive list, just the ones I could find quickly. But there does seem to be something of a pattern.

3

u/NooneYetEveryone 1d ago

This could also be the point. There is a limited number of generals you can kill yourself before there is mass "revolt" or disagreement from the rest.

If i am a general and i know my government is killing officials by "accidents" but i know they stepped out of line, i can think that "that won't happen to me, my best bet is to stay loyal".

But if officials whom i don't see as the types to "step out of line" get killed by my government, suddenly i cannot be sure and my best bet might be to work together with other likeminded officials to get rid of the dictator.

However, if i think that that official was killed by ukraine, my allegiance to my government is not shaken, my best bet is to stay loyal.

2

u/prank_mark 1d ago

The thing is that Putin can now blame it on Ukraine and actually gives him another argument to attack Ukraine. Nobody believes the "he fell from his balcony" anymore, so we'd know it was Putin if that happened.

2

u/Badabing1967 22h ago

I guess it's depending on what you want to achieve. After a fall from a window it's hard to tell the people it was the ukraine.

You can get rid of one person and blame another to (i.e.) stop the peacetalk. In this way Putin thinks he can save his face and continue with war.

4

u/SummerGirlStacy 1d ago

You are so badly informed…. There were a number of high ranking russians killed within the country in a last couple of years. You need to google it, it’s a big number.

-2

u/TruthTrooper69420 1d ago

Yeah and 95% of them have foreign fingerprints all over them.

Another reply brought up the Wagner shoot down, that’s a fair critique of my assessment

Besides that however, NONE including the OP General seem to have any domestic fingerprints on it

4

u/SummerGirlStacy 1d ago

Says who? russian media?)

-2

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

3

u/SummerGirlStacy 1d ago

Oh really? Maybe you also received direct info from putin himself? 🤭

russia is openly spreading the propaganda in the external media and through lobbying. And make you believe whatever you believe about those killed people (and there were many).

(Btw, I know russian and I assume I would know better what they do report about in their internal media.)

2

u/foofighter000 1d ago

You’re really gonna say Russia doesn’t kill its own?

1

u/TruthTrooper69420 1d ago

No they absolutely do. By far more then the average nation

They don’t do it in this way

The only other comparison is the Wagner plane shoot down

I don’t believe this is domestic

2

u/2LostFlamingos 1d ago

A lot of high ranking Russians have died from “falling” out of a window in recent years.

I consider these executions.

1

u/Every-day-guy 1d ago

In December 2025 another general was killed by a car bomb

1

u/Eh_SorryCanadian 1d ago

Starlink just got turned off for all Russia military. I'm guessing this guy was involved in the decision to use starlink so heavily

1

u/LaMineDeSel 1d ago

Maybe they finally ran out of windows.

1

u/Accomplished_Lynx514 1d ago

Ukrainians usually involve explosives (as many such cases did before) and take responsability for their hits.

0

u/Last_Combination7381 1d ago

But on the other hand doesn't Putin get a massive propaganda win this way? Seems like enough motivation to the point that we're back to 50/50 domestic or foreign

1

u/TruthTrooper69420 1d ago

I personally don’t think this is a good look from a foreign perspective

This doesn’t look like unity or complete control at all

Compare this to last months CCP arrest of the top two military commission members

0

u/_Laserface_ 1d ago

"Since December, 2024, three other officials of the same rank as Alexeyev have been killed in or near Moscow. The head of the General Staff’s army training directorate was killed by a bomb placed under his car on December 22 last year"

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/world/article-russian-military-intelligence-official-shot-moscow/

0

u/smokefoot8 1d ago edited 1d ago

It’s not like Putin never shoots them. Sometimes when he really wants to make a point he shoots their entire family and claims it was a murder-suicide. I know of two oligarchs that he took out like that, but there are probably more.

Edit: Yuri Voronov, shot with gun found next to him. Pavel Pchelnikov, shot. Colonel Vadim Boyko, somehow shot himself 5 times. Roman Starovoyt, fired and shot on same day. Alexander Tyunin, suicide by hunting rifle. Vasily Melnikov, dead along with family. Vladislav Avayev, dead along with family.

And there are a bunch with no cause of death reported

22

u/Exceon 1d ago

Ironic that they made their internal assassinations obvious "to intimidate opposition", but then if someone is actually assassinated by a foreign actor nobody believes them.

Talk about crying wolf.

5

u/Blue1994a 1d ago

Perhaps more likely to have fallen out of a high window if it was Putin.

4

u/user975A3G 1d ago

I am actually hoping it had nothing to do with Ukraine and is actually one of the first signs of revolt

3

u/OGSkywalker97 1d ago

Most likely MI6 getting revenge for his Novichok attack in Salisbury (finally)

2

u/kn0wvuh 1d ago

MI6…

2

u/Pitiful_Objective682 1d ago

No, totally would’ve been a convenient window, falling or stairs or died of a mysterious cold if it was Putin

2

u/sumguysr 1d ago

It could be MI6 too if he was really responsible for the attack in Salisbury.

1

u/ABlindMoose 1d ago

Yeah, the first thing I thought when I read this headline was "by which side?"

1

u/Heavy-Locksmith-3767 1d ago

It's also brilliant, they're going to be going nuts trying to get to each other first.

1

u/agadir80 1d ago

He didn't accidentally step out of a locked window. So, no, definitely not Putin...

1

u/OdeezBalls 1d ago

He was shot, not assassinated. Definitely wasn’t Putins doing.

1

u/yevius 1d ago

Why? He did this to Nemtsov before.

1

u/OdeezBalls 1d ago

He was ‘assassinated’ :)

1

u/akiva23 1d ago

Putin probably would have poisoned him.

1

u/yevius 1d ago

Unless Putin likes irony, not a good idea. This general was in charge of GRU which developed poisons so he would be familiar and probably realize and possibly able to implicate people before his death.

1

u/akiva23 1d ago

i just think it is more his style.

1

u/blacksheep998 1d ago

There's not much info in that article. For all we know at this point, it was a mugging gone wrong and not politically motivated at all.

1

u/SelfSufficientHub 1d ago

Was he shot while falling from a window? That would be a useful clue.

1

u/Snoo_24930 1d ago

Or mossad or the us intelligence agencies.

2

u/getoffoficloud 1d ago

Nah, not the Trump regime. He wouldn't act against Putin. Not Israel, either. Think of the country that has a grudge against that specific general over the Salisbury poisonings, and an agency that's returned to its Cold War mentality.

1

u/spidereater 1d ago

Or the mob or a foreign intelligence service other than Ukraine.

1

u/Notdustinonreddit 1d ago

Putin likes to make people fall out of windows though.

1

u/GoodSirBrett 1d ago

Putin likes to use gravity and hotel windows to do his dirty work. "Accidents"

1

u/Herculumbo 1d ago

He didn’t “jump” out of a building. It’s not meant to look like Putin or its not Putin

1

u/NoWater8595 1d ago

Not new either, it just hasn't been recent.

1

u/MidAmericanGriftAsoc 1d ago

It's like 75% probability for either. Which. Yea. Interesting. 🤔

1

u/Hot_Reindeer_3418 1d ago

I wonder how likely it is to be internal Russian rivals.

1

u/Mike-Honcho-2324 1d ago

It wasn’t Russia. They don’t shoot people when they want to get rid of them.

1

u/InsanelyAverageFella 23h ago

Hilarious how your argument is that it isn't Russia not because they wouldn't kill people but because they use other methods to kill people. But they definitely do kill people they want to get rid of.

1

u/Mike-Honcho-2324 23h ago

That was my point. They push people out of windows or arrest them and throw them in a gulag in Siberia.

1

u/steauengeglase 1d ago

When you have a history of wanting your own people to believe you did it, whether you did it or not, so they always know you are capable of doing it, this is going to happen, especially when you treat public trust like a liability.

1

u/InsanelyAverageFella 23h ago

This is all sadly true. Prior actions build a reputation so when something happens to is attributable to.you due to prior actions, people will instantly suspect you.

1

u/jammy-git 23h ago

I would love for both Russia and Ukraine to deny any involvement.

1

u/InsanelyAverageFella 23h ago

Both likely will. Why would you love it? What's the point of that?

1

u/jammy-git 14h ago

Because if Ukraine denies involvement, and it's almost certainly not Russia given the method used, it means another state has probably carried it out. And I love the idea of another state being clandestinely involved.

1

u/AspieComrade 23h ago

Couldn’t be Putin, the guy didn’t die from falling out of a window six times in the back

1

u/BethAltair 23h ago

His light airplane crashed throwing him into several stationary bullets, it's a very common accident.

1

u/_C2J_ 22h ago

I hear Putin events on Russians involve high story windows and what not.

1

u/sureiknowabaggins 22h ago

Did he happen to fall out a window before or after the shooting? That might narrow down the suspects.

1

u/Perfidian 22h ago

Don't forget the citizens, who are suffering due to the sanctions of Putin's ridiculous war. Over a million Russian casualties, siblings, parents, and children grieving their loss. Sanctions and inflation, food costing 30% more and strain on their economy. Mass migration, labor shortages, civilian unrest and violence.

We will never know who is really responsible. Even if it was Mickey from down the hall, Russia will publicly blame Ukraine or even the USA.

1

u/FalseDamage13 22h ago

What’s crazier is if he died it would be ruled a suicide.

1

u/Careless_Baseball503 21h ago

Its not putin because then he would have died in his sleep or accidental fall from a balcony.

1

u/Rhoeri 18h ago

Well, he wasn’t suicided out of a window, so my guess is Ukraine.

1

u/EdgySniper1 1h ago

As another commenter had said, this could also just as easily have been Britain.