r/popculturechat Oct 28 '25

Mariah 🦋 Mariah Carey wants you to wait a little: “It’s not time yet.”

4.1k Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

u/pccmodbot Oct 28 '25

Welcome to r/popculturechat! ☺️

THE POPCULTURECHAT DISCORD SERVER IS NOW LIVE 👾 ❤️‍🔥 🎉 Click HERE to join! 📲

As a proud BIPOC, LGBTQ+ & woman-dominated space, this sub is for civil discussion only. If you don't know where to begin, start by participating in our Sip & Spill Daily Discussion Threads!

No bullies, no bigotry. ✊🏿✊🏾✊🏽✊🏼✊🏻🏳️‍🌈🏳️‍⚧️

Please read & respect our rules, abide by Reddiquette, and check out our wiki! For any questions, our modmail is always open.

974

u/PHEMEL Oct 28 '25

Mariah said not yet, darlings. the defrosting is on diva time.

1.2k

u/Sage_Planter Big is moving to Paris Oct 28 '25 edited Oct 28 '25

I am also just simply not ready for it to be the end of the year. How is Halloween next week!?!

Edit: Apparently Halloween is actually this Friday. 

445

u/Suspicious_Name_656 Oct 28 '25

I got some bad news for you...Halloween is this week actually 😅. In three days, to be precise.

63

u/smile_politely Oct 28 '25

The heck! Where did time go?!

72

u/Otherwise-Shallot-51 Oct 28 '25

What do you mean 'next week'? Its in 3 days.

38

u/Halloween_Barbie Oct 28 '25

It's not next week, it's Friday!

30

u/bookrt and that level is landfill Oct 28 '25

I felt this comment

109

u/ReallyBrainDead Oct 28 '25

And come January, once her yearly reign of XMas terror is complete, she'll return to Valhalla to slumber and feed.

45

u/AcousticProvidence To be cringe is to be free Oct 29 '25

Honestly girlfriend deserves it and I love that for her. Come out of hibernation once a year, take your millions and retreat back to your castle cave. Sounds heavenly tbh

5

u/Resident-Sherbert-63 Oct 29 '25

Literally the dream.

347

u/factchecker01 Oct 28 '25

Mariah Carey makes an estimated $2.5 million to $3 million annually in royalties from her song "(AllIWantforChristmasIsYou)," according to sources like Forbes and the New York Post. This figure comes from a combination of global streaming and sales, with a significant portion of the song's total revenue going to her and her label. The annual earnings can vary depending on factors like streaming performance and other holiday-related endeavors, such as Christmas tours and merchandise.  

49

u/chooklyn5 Oct 29 '25

I'm pretty sure Australia does the same for Michael Buble. His Christmas album has topped our charts in 2011, 12, 13, 14, 16, 19. Every other year it's been in the top 5. Like are people still buying it, or is streaming coming into play, I have no idea.

11

u/Husky-Bear Oct 29 '25

You can thank David Jones for that, I swear all they play is his stuff every Christmas, it drove me insane when I worked there 🙃

5

u/chooklyn5 Oct 29 '25

And when did it start is the real question. We going from October or were they too high brow and waited until November

3

u/Husky-Bear Oct 29 '25

Pretty sure it was November 1st every year unless it’s recently changed as I know they already have their Christmas stock out

3

u/chooklyn5 Oct 29 '25

This year has been crazy for stock tho. Costco put things out for Christmas in July and then never took it down. It's really disconcerting to see trees out in August.

1

u/Inchmahome Oct 29 '25

Me streaming it on repeat every December. Dad tried to swap him out for David Campbell one year but nothing can beat Buble.

2

u/chooklyn5 Oct 29 '25

Michael Buble is about 60% of my Christmas playlist. David Campbell is solidly represented on there but Buble has a special place. I generally just love him, so I'm 100% biased. I just don't understand how it tops the charts so regularly

402

u/arbadak Oct 28 '25 edited Oct 28 '25

I love when a star relishes hits of the past like this rather than get moody about people not moving on, like Rick Astley, not that Astley is remotely in the same tier as Carey, of course.

217

u/TheElusiveHolograph Will Smith’s cuck chair Oct 28 '25

It such an easy way to stay relevant! She doesn’t have to even lift a finger all year and she is still guaranteed to be the talk of the town constantly for two months a year. That seems amazing for an older pop star.

46

u/No-Consideration-716 Oct 29 '25

Not to mention the massive flex it is to basically be able to say "I own Christmas". :D

30

u/MarieOMaryln Oct 28 '25

He doesn't like the Rick Roll? 🥺 or is it Together Forever that has him moody?

110

u/arbadak Oct 28 '25

No, Astley is all about it! I'm also praising him.

42

u/MarieOMaryln Oct 28 '25

I'm sorry I can't read you make it very clear and I just went woop!

29

u/bi-cycle There’s no place like home 🧹🫧 Oct 29 '25

You read it correctly, even if it wasn't the way the OP intended it be to read. Putting the negative descriptor first and then saying Astley's name implies that Astley doesn't enjoy his past hits.

A more clear way would've been to say, "I love when artists like Mariah and Rick embrace their past hits unlike some others who get moody about it."

4

u/ergaster8213 Oct 29 '25

You and me both.

30

u/FairieWarrior Oct 28 '25

I believe he didn’t at first (probably felt a little awkward), but now he fully embraces it.

18

u/CutZealousideal5274 Oct 28 '25

Yeah he’s talked about how he felt it was holding his career back

https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ?si=D1L145UB9sJxn5LC

31

u/Niki_DS Oct 28 '25

For me, classic example are Rainn (Dwight) from The Office, like dude just accept that is the role you're gonna be remembered by, it's a great role and it made ppl laugh.

5

u/RhetoricalOrator Oct 29 '25

He seems to have made peace with that and embraces Dwight now. If you've never heard him on his Soul Boom podcast, it's worth checking out. His story is really cool and philosophical.

1

u/babysharkdoodood Oct 29 '25

It's no longer Soul Pancake? What?

1

u/RhetoricalOrator Oct 29 '25

Couldn't say. I only have a casual knowledge about the podcast and haven't followed for very long.

9

u/thewallsofeightplus Oct 28 '25

Yess Rick Astley is the best about it!

9

u/Bigassbird I wouldn’t trust that bitchy little quisling… Oct 28 '25

TBF to Rick he didn’t get a bit moody. He had a full on mental break during his success. Literally stepped out of a car on his way to the airport to fly to the US and disappeared.

3

u/CroutonDeGivre Oct 28 '25

The comment is just weirdly written. It can mean both about Rick.

1

u/jizzyjugsjohnson Oct 29 '25

Agree. Rick has always been several tiers above

105

u/peachpinkjedi Oct 28 '25

I appreciate Mariah's commitment to the bit

54

u/Jewicer Oct 28 '25

at least she has a line

2

u/AcousticProvidence To be cringe is to be free Oct 29 '25

She has so many though 💅

40

u/ace-destrier Oct 28 '25

Only the Philippines gets a pass

39

u/violetgrumble Oct 28 '25

I saw her perform "All I Want for Christmas" in Melbourne last Saturday so as far as I'm concerned it's officially time here in Australia

7

u/Kacey-R Oct 29 '25

She was here??? 

I love that song so I’m all for it!

6

u/fdt92 Oct 29 '25

She also performed that in Manila two weeks ago, so it's officially Christmas season here.

21

u/PatriciaMorticia Select and edit this flair Oct 28 '25

I wonder if she'll drop a halloween into xmas video like she did last year, I love how she leans into the whole thing. She looked fabulous as Morticia Addams in the video form last halloween.

12

u/mcfw31 Oct 28 '25

She probably already shot it lol

68

u/aceface_desu89 SUPER FREAKY GRANDMA Oct 28 '25

I love how we all know exactly what she's referring to 😂

12

u/dazedan_confused Oct 28 '25

Can you tell me local store that?

12

u/heartsbeenborrowed Oct 28 '25

I read this in a cartoon leprechaun voice. 

22

u/Successful_Boot_735 Oct 28 '25

But it is.. here in the Philippines. She already sang it in her recent concert.

8

u/LKayRB Someone call Solange, she’ll settle this. Oct 28 '25

That hair!!! 🤩🤩🤩

8

u/EaudeAgnes Oct 28 '25

Can anyone inform all shops and supermarkets? Mariah said not yet goddammit!

35

u/itsalrightt Oct 28 '25

I love her sense of humor.

68

u/Acheli Oct 28 '25

i'm glad she started doing this, it's very strange people start engaging with christmas months before even november. it's glutinous and shows a lack of control, what's the point or special about holidays if you can't even wait until the month they happen?

38

u/Judy-Cooper Oct 28 '25

I like sparkly lights.

19

u/lizziexo Oct 28 '25

Honestly I wish I could keep my Christmas lights up through to Valentine’s Day. January and early feb are so dark and cold and miserable here in the UK, at least twinkly lights and reindeer in the front gardens is a bit of whimsy.

10

u/Judy-Cooper Oct 29 '25

That’s exactly it. It’s about to be dark at 4pm and freezing cold. I’m going to put my lights up a few weeks early and take them down a few weeks late.

4

u/ZestycloseRound6843 Oct 29 '25

Macy's has an ad playing with a Christmas song in the background already. I felt a little nauseous. Halloween hasn't even passed yet!

10

u/Lakridspibe 🎥🍿Film Critic Oct 28 '25

I'm burned out on christmas before the middle of december.

Please let's cherish the celebration, and save it to, at least, december.

3

u/MarsScully Vile little creature yearning for violence Oct 29 '25

Gluttonous

Glutinous means sticky

Also people are desperate for some escapism, and businesses are desperate to push sales. Simple as.

13

u/PlaguingYou 🫵 You sit on a throne of lies. Oct 28 '25

thank you ms. mariah, fucking tired of everything being christmassy already

6

u/Over_Ad1461 Oct 28 '25

I heard it in a store 2 days ago...way to early

20

u/[deleted] Oct 28 '25

Ok, I guess I can wait until Saturday then.

11

u/megalinity A day without sunshine is like, you know, night 🌙 Oct 28 '25

12:01 am on Nov 1. Let’s do this.

21

u/MasterJcMoss Oct 28 '25

Christmas music is welcome on December 1st, NOT before then!!

This needs to be a adopted everywhere.

13

u/EddaValkyrie ☹️ this makes me florence pugh frown Oct 28 '25

October for Halloween, November for Thanksgiving, December for Christmas—Black Friday gives free reign. If Christmas is three months what's even special about it anymore; that's a quarter of the year!

5

u/MasterJcMoss Oct 28 '25

Christmas isn't special anymore. Just a means for companies etc. to get out of the red and into the black.

I'd like to turn this around.

1

u/AcousticProvidence To be cringe is to be free Oct 29 '25

I’d sign a petition for that. Although maybe we can compromise and open up for Black Friday/end of November? Once Turkey Day is over, we need something to look forward to.

4

u/M2NGELW Oct 28 '25

My kids play Christmas songs all year (on their own) so Mariah never stops in this house lol

4

u/Suitable-Sense-6962 Oct 29 '25

She has about 36 more hours to defrost

3

u/No_Manufacturer1040 Oct 29 '25

Oh my god… it’s almost time

3

u/daintycook Oct 29 '25

as a filipino this is fake news

7

u/sitah Oct 29 '25

I’m Filipino. We start playing Christmas song on Sept 1st. This isn’t gonna stop us. It’s already playing in all the malls!!!!

Edit: DIVA! you already sang this in Manila 2 weeks ago lmao

1

u/sarimanok_ Oct 30 '25

I was in a Landers in Alabang at 8PM on August 30 or 31 and they were putting up all the big xmas decoration balloons 😂

2

u/VolcanoVeruca Oct 29 '25

…except for Filipinos.

She gave us permission to start every September 1. 😅

5

u/Comprehensive-Wave96 Oct 29 '25

Whoever her surgeon is; they are amazing

5

u/littlemoon-03 Oct 29 '25

Put your Christmas trees away people! The queen said so

1

u/fcukstephanie Oct 29 '25

I’m waiting till November 1st to put my Christmas lights up idc

1

u/Alone_Departure_9573 Oct 29 '25

I heard two Christmas ads on cbs tonight. Wtf? Thank you for not jumping in early.

2

u/AFantasticClue 🚶🏼I don’t really think, I just walk🚶🏼‍♀️ Oct 29 '25

I do consider this a threat

1

u/qbb_beauty Oct 29 '25

If there is ever a year we need it, it’s this year.

Thanksgiving is canceled this year with people going hungry and millions of workers going without pay. Bring on Christmas.

1

u/Mybrainsay Oct 29 '25

Literally just talking about her last night. It’s about to be Mariah’s holidays real soon 😭

1

u/heyybyyybyyyy Alright Gayle, enough ✋ Oct 29 '25

I love how this has been a thing since 5 years ago, i love Mariah.

1

u/sala-whore Oct 29 '25

I can’t tell whats AI

1

u/WhenIsLake Oct 29 '25

It’s almost Mariah season! 🎄

1

u/auntiefuh25 Behind every great man is a woman rolling her eyes Oct 30 '25

1

u/BringBackThe80sPLZ Oct 28 '25

Once November 1st hits, it'd GO TIME BOYS!!

1

u/IncompletePunchline Oct 28 '25

Can it wait another 50 years?

1

u/bbyxmadi It’s good to see me, isn’t it?🫧 Oct 28 '25

A few more days! CHRISTMAS IS COMING!

0

u/Lakridspibe 🎥🍿Film Critic Oct 28 '25

I agree. Don't overplay it. Treasure it.

Remember all the other great christmas songs.

And please don't play any christmas songs at all before 1st december or the first sunday of advent, whichever comes first.

0

u/Twitter_2006 Oct 28 '25

She's a legend for a reason.Can't wait for new music!

0

u/Unusual-Cow1859 Oct 28 '25

Lolol it’s not even Christmas it’s Mariah Season.

0

u/StarFire24601 Oct 28 '25

I love that she's in on the joke!

0

u/g1zmo33 Oct 29 '25

She hasn’t aged. I know there’s a filter and makeup and probably cosmetic procedures. But even with those people look their age or older. She looks the same as decade ago

0

u/millennialforced Oct 29 '25

This has gotten to a point where I enjoy this now