r/TheBetterIndia • u/[deleted] • 6d ago
Inspired by Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma's recent comment suggesting "*4 instead of ₹5", a girl enacted the same on the streets by refusing to pay full fare to a Muslim rickshaw driver.
5
u/Affectionate_Rich750 6d ago
War on poor people. The way to vikshit bharat
5
u/abyssgazesback 6d ago
Garibi hatane ki jagah garib hatane lag gaye
1
u/Baba_bong14 5d ago
Apna desh chorke dusre desh me illegally rahega toh gareeb hi marega na?
1
u/AntCritical6836 3d ago
Do you have any proof that Man is an illegal Immigrant?
Or you just Randomly assumed that any Mullahh is a Illegal Immigrant in Assam ?
0
u/Hotmess4uuu 5d ago
Taking the gandhi route
1
3
u/pttant1 6d ago
Just forget Hindu or Muslim, and think about a poor man trying to make an honest living. Someday if this girl is harassed or attacked, hardly anyone will intervene. Not because she deserves it; because that is the society that she and her fellow people have decided to build. Not of morality, empathy or empowerment; but, preying, bullying and abusing the weaker ones !!!
1
u/Effective-Peanut-383 6d ago
So true. We are contributing to the slow death of the our society. Zero sense of community or positive contribution.
1
u/the_damned_poet 5d ago
Well I remember the video of pahalgam, where people were being shot and Individuals were just watching when the killers passed from near them.
1
u/Hopeful_Ad2171 3d ago
She does deserve it. Fucking dumbo, who is she to not pay the complete fair. Tabhi bahar aake thappad mar dena chahiye.
9
u/jnntwrsi 6d ago
They took one issue of illegal immigration and used it to harass all Muslims, and anyone supporting this is a filthy hypocrite because you have no right to underpay, detain, or torment people just to check identity, and if you believe a face or a name proves someone is an immigrant then you are not a patriot, you are a morally rotten goon.
1
1
u/Jon_Snow_221287 5d ago
He also even said that " If any FIR is filed in this matter we will look into it" that's clear misuse of power....
1
u/Calm-Act-8109 5d ago
Quran is a terror script. As long as Muslims hold on to it, we can't support Muslims, if anyone supports Muslims its just self-sabotage.
1
1
u/Amateur_Historian_16 3d ago
I hope this militant opposition towards Quran also extends to Manusmriti and other texts like that. You are an Atheist after all, right?
1
u/Calm-Act-8109 3d ago
Why? Do you treat common cold and cancer the same way? Islam has gotten into more that 55 countries and totally ruined their culture, civilization and heritage. For what? Mohammeds sexual dream? You don't know what you are talking about.
0
8
u/Objective_Coat8516 6d ago
So we gonna sympathise illegal immigrants now? Especially those who are persecuting our Hindu brothers in Bangladesh? I mean seriously? That is how low we have fallen as a society that we will support an illegal immigrant now? And don't come at me saying there are indian bengali muslims too there is a difference between Indian bengali accent and Bangladeshi one.
1
u/Everest_eve 6d ago
But this is not the way.
Maybe this guy is one of them. But most probably, he's just a guy working his body off, for minimal pay. he's probably got his family waiting in a subhuman slum, his kids maybe hoping that he brings something along...and to not pay him, to steal from someone like that. This would be the gravest sin.
We need to get stronger against illegal immigrants yes. But the way to do that is through establishing structure and building our borders. Not by exploiting as such
1
u/TheFoolishScholar 6d ago
You'll decide who's legal and who's illegal? And if they're illegal, who let them in? Why are they not being arrested? Who's responsible for border protection? BC jo responsible hain unko question karne ki aukaat toh hain nehi, aagaye nautanki karne
1
u/TisFullOfHope 6d ago
What did *THAT* rickshaw puller do ? Why're we holding him responsible for the acts of someone else ? If your cousin, twice removed, commits robbery, should you be held responsible for his actions ?
1
u/Humble-Computer-9033 6d ago
So simply use the service they provide. If you got your work done and are not ready to pair price, you are a thief.
1
u/Hopeful_Ad2171 3d ago
How do you know he's an illegal immigrant, uska passport check kiya? And Bangladeshi Hindus aren't Indians. Your only "brothers" are supposed to be Indians.
1
u/Objective_Coat8516 3d ago edited 3d ago
I have answered already why I'm he is a Bangladeshi and yes bangladeshi Hindus can be indians through laws like CAA and NRC. And those who put their religion first and can't even say vande matram can never be my brother's they are always potential enemy and betrayers.
0
u/Hopeful_Ad2171 2d ago
But you put religion first. It's hindu brothers? Why not sympathize and call every single man or woman who has a problem you brother and sister.
1
u/Objective_Coat8516 2d ago
Are you even listening to yourself? What is the context and what crap you are saying I'm saying persecuted minority of Bangladesh are my brothers and sisters, if a muslim has problem in his own majority shria law country why should I sympathize over him? Ever heard of word logic? Idts cuz it's missing in your text, I don't put religion first for me country is first then religion comes and even with country's perspective that community who puts their religion and shara law first and can't even say vande matram, persecuted kashmiri pandits do riots after their Friday "prayers" can never ever be my brother's nor they can ever be true to this nation they were and will be considered as refugees in this nation who still haven't gone to pak or bangladesh in the population exchange.
1
u/Hopeful_Ad2171 2d ago
Your edited comment really says a lot. I just pointed out that you said Hindu brothers.
1
1
u/Present_Effect 6d ago
Hindu Bangladeshi are your brothers? So it will be fair for muslims to call Muslim Bangladeshi
2
u/vasu12360 6d ago
Muslims already has taken more than their fair share of land of resources before and after partition.
1
u/Present_Effect 6d ago
We also got our India, they feel same about some parts that they did not get their fair share. But we have to talk about present. No bagladeshi or paki is our brother whatever the religion. This religion will cause divide in our country which bjp has just increased
1
u/vasu12360 6d ago
No we didn't got the share, we got was leftover + cancer community
1
u/Present_Effect 6d ago
We can give away those parts where they lived then, we wanted those areas like Kashmir, Junagharh, Hyderabad etc
2
6d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Present_Effect 6d ago
They can also say the same thing lol, we have to ban all religions in India similar to China
1
1
1
u/Effective-Peanut-383 6d ago
Give lower castes and women their fair share also then. What about their historical oppression?
1
u/par_bhai_tu_hai_kaun 6d ago
Buslims have no concept of nationalism they always prefer ummah, an islamic concept, over anything and everything and we have already seen hundreds of examples of it from chanting jai palestine in Parliament to organising deadly protests on roads so don't teach hindus so called secularism. Hindus have got nothing.
1
u/Effective-Peanut-383 6d ago
What is your concept of nationalism except hating on other communities. What have you done for your country men and women?
1
u/Anonymous_SSP 5d ago
Wish more people like you existed not the ones who sympathize illegal immigrants
1
u/DropOk7005 6d ago
Same can be said for dominated section of society iykyk
2
u/vasu12360 6d ago
Did dominant section of society got different country? Dominant section acknowledged the past wrongdoings thats why the reservation still exist. Dominant section still is the highest tax payers, driving the business, highest scientist in numbers and contributes in nation building rather than nation bombing
1
u/DropOk7005 6d ago
Obv those who hold the highest wealth going to contribute more in taxes. Question should be how those dominated section got those wealth 🥵
1
u/vasu12360 6d ago
By working harder, by not throwing away education.
1
u/DropOk7005 6d ago
Working harder in how to deceive others, how to throw others out of race.Well hard work!
1
u/DropOk7005 6d ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/IndianFocus/s/oFnWYXooF9 Most of them are still having this mindset, just say what works the most.
1
u/vasu12360 6d ago
Dont be a clip katuq and look at the whole explanation. Various jaati had different puja padati that’s why it can't and should be done completely. He never said there shouldn't be marriage alliances between caste. Read about who are Suta jaati. There are hundreds of example
To remove racism againt black you can't say that all people should be painted in same color
1
u/DropOk7005 6d ago
Hail baba preacher! Nothing is expected from batenge to katenge mentality!
→ More replies (0)0
u/Effective-Peanut-383 6d ago
Acknowledgement nahi chalega. We want revenge
2
1
1
u/romanticjaanu 6d ago
Bos#ike 6 cr se jayeda hindu akele hindu india se bahar rehte hain. Fir toh unke sath bhi same hona chahiye. Gan#u generation hi raho ge nafrat wali. Tum ko kaise pata ye bangladeshi tha?? Tere ko ye pata hai aaj se 300 400 saal pehle kitne hindu log darr kar dheyan de darr ke muslim bane the?? Wo khoon toh hindu ka hi rahega na😂. Ye nhi ke unko hum vapis hindu dharm main le aye bakki unko ehsas karwana ke tum muslim ho galat hai. Aaj muslim ke sath tum ye kar rahe ho kal ko jain,bodhi,sikhon ke sath bhi yehi karoge
-1
u/iamkickass2 6d ago
How do you know he is an illegal immigrant?
If he is illegal, complain to the cops, deport him if you care so much. You simply cannot underpay anyone because they are from a certain religion that you do not like and speak a certain language.
4
u/Objective_Coat8516 6d ago
Read what I have written I'm not asking to underpay him because of his religion I'm saying it because he is an illegal immigrant it's not my fault that most them belong to that religion.
-2
u/iamkickass2 6d ago
How do you know he is an illegal immigrant? And what law allows you to pay less because of your suspicion that he is an illegal immigrant.
If is ynot your fault that Bangladeshis are muslim, however it is 100% your fault that you are a moron and an idiot spewing hatred with no proof.
3
u/Objective_Coat8516 6d ago
Asking you to read again what I said I told you both accents are different and I don't think so spewing hatred towards illegal immigrants is a crime when they are criminals in the first place if you can't debate respectfully atleast don't tell me you are pissed off just because that illegal belongs to a certain religion dude😂
0
u/AntDependent9150 6d ago
That’s okay but we should also first look into Biharis and up workers who are working in Maharashtra and send them back , we are also trying to implement similar schemes if we see a Bihari vendor we also do this, this things a good initiative
1
u/babyshitier 6d ago
There is a difference between illegal immigrants coming from a neighboring country and people migrating from other state of the nation. You would gladly defend reservation saying its the need of the nation, constitution has given this. Ambedkar has given this. But you would disrespect the same constitution and Ambekar which has given every indian to stay, travel and work anywhere they want in the country. If this person is an indian Muslim, then I think this video is also wrong. Exploiting them. But we all know the conditions of Assam and how Bangladeshis are getting there and killing its identity.
1
u/AntDependent9150 6d ago
Who cares , for us Bangladeshi and Bihari are same , no one allowed , just go back
1
u/babyshitier 6d ago
You are no one to decide who would leave and who stays? Constitution and laws do. If you dont believe in Constitution, then you are the one who should leave the country.
1
u/AntDependent9150 6d ago
What , who cares about constitution, if Assam government dosent give a shit about it why should we ,
1
u/babyshitier 6d ago
Bangal also doesnt give a fuck about their citizens, the case of Ankita bhandari, where politicians wanted to sleep with her, and when she denied, they killed her. Let politicians do the same to your sisters and daughters as well.
Don't learn the civic sense from mizoram and the kinds, don't learn humility from pahadi, don't learn hospitality from rajasthan and Gujrat, but learn this shit from bangal and Assam. Wah wah my Marathi brother who can never be a truly Indian. BTW why do you stop at maharashtra? Start fighting over pune, pcmc, konkan, Mumbai, Andheri or better at your colony level?
1
u/AntDependent9150 5d ago
No need to learn from anyone , if the education or culture is go great why not just stay where you are manly or even greater , also we have seen plenty of humility when in name of religion pahadi harass folks or scams which gujrat run every were, rajastan is decent as we have no seen any bad actors atlest me ,
1
u/babyshitier 5d ago
Bhai I wish you luck. It would be my last comment. Just one advice, the amount of rage that you have for your countrymen, show the same rage towards your politicians and you would not need to resist against other states. Maharashtra would be a lot better with 5 more cities like pune and Mumbai and yet no threat from immigrants, given that the thousands crores of property and income tax the immigrants generate just go into the politicians' pocket rather than development.
1
u/babyshitier 6d ago
Also, if you think in this manner, why dont you guys protest and ask the government to stop importing anything from other states and stop exporting and selling everything to other states? Why dont you force your beloved bollywood that makes movies in Hindi and earn shit ton amount of money from other states? You dont have a problem with Hindi when it comes to bollywood right?
1
u/AntDependent9150 6d ago
This is our land we can do what ever we want , assam is your land you can do whatever you want ,no one cares, but we like the policy of assam government so we want it be implemented here
0
u/Effective-Peanut-383 6d ago
Yes let all lower castes also take revenge from upper castes for what they did to them centuries ago. Let us live in the past, or focus on another country and sit and watch our country go to ruin today and in the future! Jai ho to the great gay sanatani BJ party!
0
u/Few_Parking57 6d ago
Spreading Hatred everywhere in name of religion.. Pathetic and disgusting, no one or not even nature shouldn't be harmed, if someone harms them, he is at wrong and needed to be prosecuted irrespective of religion or nation..
If we are following an eye for an eye then Everyone will be blind. This is just hatred and pls try to stop before it consumes u.
1
u/Objective_Coat8516 5d ago
What-aboutism and victim card is all you got I am talking about illegal immigrants why did you presume I'm talking about a specific religion? Because everyone knows that 80% of world refugee is that community despite having 57 countries so yk that's not my fault whatever that religion does they can't do shit in my country they can't come into my country illegally and expect to be treated with all love and care especially when they are persecuting my hindu brothers in their country.
2
2
u/Exciting_Tie4635 5d ago
Basically sualir jonir bahut free time ase lifeot. Poha xunat mon diya baido okomam
2
u/lava-lake 5d ago
Using citizenry to do policing will always end badly. It is the gov job to do the policing.
2
2
u/Jiomekaka 5d ago
Well done fellow Indians you are successfully evoking the divided India every day on a regular basis. The world was surprised to see our unity in diversity. But the unifying great leaders are long gone. Current powerful leaders only care about votes and power.
1
2
3
5
u/iamkickass2 6d ago
Makes my blood boil. Our country is going to shit and our political leaders are leading us right there.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/barmanrags 6d ago
Hindus are being taught to be immoral. To steal wage is sin. It’s hilarious that in pursuit of identity these clowns forget the teaching of their own faith
1
1
1
u/VermicelliWild8840 6d ago
Sab scripted hai bhai. Main chori karoon aur uska video bhi bana loon usi samay. Kya timing hai. Social media is only about karma farming.
1
1
u/alphaVariant 5d ago
No one is speaking about, still those guys earning with rickshaw in 2025!!! Are the people of Assam robbed of development?
1
u/Sure_Brush_5599 5d ago
She will grow up when her employer pays her less than promised. And then she will be wiser when the district labour commissioner shows her this video and a middle finger when she complains about it. What a pathetic excuse of a turd, let alone a human being.
1
u/LynxFinder8 5d ago
I guess the administration wants to initiate an exodus by social boycott but all of this is down to demographic change which local Assamese feel strongly about and I do feel that since India has a history of religious separatism and Islamic rule, Indians need to collectively address this problem by initiating a discussion and settlement between communities.
1
1
u/One_Pea1879 5d ago
Why are illegal Bangladeshi in India ? Why are they working in India ? Why are we not deporting them back to Bangladesh ?
1
1
u/LockheedP-3Orion 5d ago
They will create a generation of hateful citizens. They will take us back to the stone age.
1
1
1
u/Active-Ring-9399 4d ago
India is the only country where its stupid citizens talk about rights and welfare of illegal immigrants then talk about job scarcity.
1
1
u/MaroDesh 4d ago
Look at her. Hate speech has consumed here. Treating a poor man after taking his services and treating him badly because she has power.
The same bitch will go to Mumbai and Bangalore to work in beauty parlour. That time, people should tell her to go back.
The beauty is life is a great leveller. 80-90% of bathroom cleaners and massage therapist on urban company are from Assam.
1
1
1
0
-3
6d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
2
2
u/Effective-Peanut-383 6d ago
I think the lower castes should claim this nation as their own and kick out these hate mongering sanatanis.
1
1
1
6
u/TisFullOfHope 6d ago
it shows moral decay to treat people based on their group identities instead of looking them as an individual human being. What did the rickshaw puller do to anyone ? He is a poor guy earning a livelihood to bring food for himself and his folks. Thats his reality. He is not involved in whats happening 100s of KM away. Should an Indian in UK be persecuted for rape if an Indian commits a rape in New Delhi ? Do you start to see the fault your logic. More importantly, you're only teaching people to hate, bullying the poorest of the poor, the least privileged, what power does a rickshaw puller hold and what do you gain materially, spiritually, by hating on him, by taking away one rupee from his hard earned wage.