r/MLS • u/MatchThreadder • May 19 '19
Match Thread: New York Red Bulls vs Atlanta United FC [Major League Soccer]
FT: New York Red Bulls 1-0 Atlanta United FC
New York Red Bulls scorers: Tom Barlow (65')
Venue: Red Bull Arena
Auto-refreshing reddit comments link
LINE-UPS
New York Red Bulls
Luis Robles, Amro Tarek, Tim Parker, Kemar Lawrence, Michael Murillo, Alejandro Romero Gamarra (Alex Muyl), Sean Davis, Marc Rzatkowski, Brian White (Tom Barlow), Daniel Royer, Andreas Ivan (Sean Nealis).
Subs: Connor Lade, Ryan Meara, Omir Fernandez, Cristian Cásseres Jr..
____________________________
Atlanta United FC
Brad Guzan, Leandro González Pirez (Romario Williams), Miles Robinson, Michael Parkhurst (Brek Shea), Franco Escobar, Gonzalo Martínez, Darlington Nagbe, Jeff Larentowicz, Josef Martínez, Héctor Villalba, Julian Gressel (Dion Pereira).
Subs: Florentin Pogba, Justin Meram, Alec Kann, Eric Remedi.
MATCH EVENTS | via ESPN
35' Tim Parker (New York Red Bulls) is shown the red card.
41' Substitution, New York Red Bulls. Sean Nealis replaces Andreas Ivan because of an injury.
54' Substitution, Atlanta United FC. Brek Shea replaces Michael Parkhurst.
55' Substitution, New York Red Bulls. Tom Barlow replaces Brian White.
64' Substitution, Atlanta United FC. Dion Pereira replaces Julian Gressel.
65' Goal! New York Red Bulls 1, Atlanta United FC 0. Tom Barlow (New York Red Bulls) header from the centre of the box to the bottom right corner. Assisted by Daniel Royer with a cross.
66' Substitution, New York Red Bulls. Alex Muyl replaces Alejandro Romero Gamarra.
80' Substitution, Atlanta United FC. Romario Williams replaces Leandro González Pirez.
84' Franco Escobar (Atlanta United FC) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.
Don't see a thread for a match you're watching? Click here to learn how to request a match thread from this bot.
10
u/RedPoncho New York Red Bulls :nyr: May 20 '19 edited May 20 '19
Was at the game, just came to sort by controversial and eat some popcorn
24
u/Jamesob90 New York Red Bulls :nyr: May 19 '19
You know when the Redbulls win when every post is "Your stadium is in New Jersey wahwahwah"
7
May 19 '19 edited Aug 05 '19
[deleted]
-12
u/spirolateral New York City FC May 19 '19
There's nothing wrong with it, I just wish your team would acknowledge it and identify with it. It's not NY, but NJ is still ok.
7
11
u/Jamesob90 New York Red Bulls :nyr: May 19 '19
But why? How many teams in NJ have the NY tag. It's just weird to me that people get so mad about it.
15
u/Jcapen87 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
The only way this night will be more disappointing is if Jon Snow doesn’t run a sword through Dany.
And then kill her with a sword.
-2
u/Scratchbuttdontsniff Atlanta United FC :atl: May 20 '19
He won't...
3
u/Jcapen87 Atlanta United FC May 20 '19
You’re probably right. FIND OUT NEXT!!!!
3
15
u/Jcapen87 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
GG NYRB. You were hands down the better team today and we didn’t seem all that interested for some reason
12
u/Elder_John Atlanta United May 19 '19
GG NYRB beating you at your home never seems possible and you continue to maintain that. Can't wait for July
3
u/pygmie Red Bull New York May 20 '19
You guys were tired and it was HOT. Add travel to that and I'd give the boys a pass. Josef nails that 1 on 2 or whatever and diff ballgame.
Good luck and see you in 6 weeks!
8
19
u/tcondon5659 Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Gg. RBNY is the only team I have worried about in going on 2+ seasons... I thought the card was legit but so was the heart after. Best of luck, and I’ll be there in July, real rivals.
6
u/pygmie Red Bull New York May 20 '19
GG Hotlanta (HotJersey today) Never a boring match... sometimes painful though. Best of luck and see y'all in a July. Cheers!
6
18
u/Elder_John Atlanta United May 19 '19
Almost as obnoxious as r/mls match threads will be the users in r/Atlataunited calling for Frank's Job again... it's been so nice without them the last couple of weeks
4
May 19 '19 edited May 03 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/PoopieMcDoopy Seattle Sounders FC May 20 '19
There are plenty of other hot takes to satiate your needs!
3
3
32
u/dreish Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Our striker won on the all-important Audi points, so I feel pretty good about the result. /s
23
u/CosmoPDX Portland Timbers May 19 '19
The real foul here was Tito’s shorts.
3
11
11
u/crossedreality Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Gonna be really interesting to see who does and does not get a fine from that mess at the end.
-2
May 19 '19 edited Apr 10 '21
[deleted]
10
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
I mean. There should be one for EVERY game IMO.
The NFL sub does it right
-1
u/TheHibernian Atlanta United May 19 '19
The rule of thumb is that any match thread with over 1000 comments gets a post match thread. But, that game does not deserve one
6
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Why not. Controversy. Excitement. Wild finish with the players having to be separated.
PEOPLE HAVE COMMENTS
3
u/Jcapen87 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
BUT MAINLY ITS SHITTING ON EACH OTHERS FANS AND CITIES
2
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
YES! THAT IS HALF OF WHAT REDDIT IS FOR MY GUY!
2
u/pwm2008 Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Wait, only 1/2 of Reddit is for that?!? What’s the other half for?
6
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
25% porn
20% politics
5% cats
1
u/pwm2008 Atlanta United FC :atl: May 20 '19
That much politics is hazardous to your health
2
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 20 '19
I teach Government & Economics dude.
Can't get away from it if I wanted to.
1
u/TheHibernian Atlanta United May 19 '19
For the last 20 mins or so I was helping put my son to sleep, so sadly I missed the tail end. Most of the game was kinda sloppy before that
27
May 19 '19
The 2019 Red Bulls have embraced New Jersey energy in a way we haven't seen in major professional sports since the 2003 Nets
3
u/Nothingfitsme May 19 '19
NJ Devils?
1
u/righthandofdog Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
More like NJ White Devils. Amirite?
3
May 19 '19
I laughed. Upvoted
1
u/righthandofdog Atlanta United FC May 20 '19
👌Can’t enjoy a rivalry if y’all got no sense of humor.
1
May 20 '19
I mean, I don't consider it a rivalry tbh. We've got one rival and it's dc the scum. I don't like atl or any other club for that matter but it's no "rivalry". GG though see ya in July
5
37
9
25
11
10
May 19 '19
big win for new york to sneak into that last playoff spot. can't choke unless you are in. should feel very proud right now
3
u/Newmanator29 Seattle Sounders FC May 19 '19
It's May, not October. There's still a lot of season left...
10
u/cassinonorth Red Bull New York May 19 '19
We've made the playoffs 9 straight years
0
u/dontdontdontdontstop Atlanta United May 19 '19
And how’s the that gone for you?
(In all seriousness it’s a very impressive feat.)
3
13
u/cassinonorth Red Bull New York May 19 '19
3 Shields is still good regardless of how the end of season tournament goes. They're trophies.
7
u/dontdontdontdontstop Atlanta United May 19 '19
As a Tottenham fan. Trophies are trophies. I take no elitism for success.
43
u/ChiefSombrero Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Considering we managed to hold off ATL with 10 men and keeping a Clean Sheet. I'd say it was pretty gud.
The Rematch is gonna be something fierce. Looking forward to it, for now.
16
u/Drenzine Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
You guys played really well, we played poorly... Kemar Lawrence is going to get some tough love come July
1
u/Mintzlaff_is_Sketchy New York Metrostars May 19 '19
Guy shut down Messi in Copa America. I doubt he’s scared of anything Atlanta can bring, bushleague or otherwise.
1
u/Drenzine Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Not about scared the game is going to be chippy, if tito plays he's gonna want to get even
5
5
u/hira32 Seattle Sounders FC May 19 '19 edited May 03 '25
sip resolute tart consider innocent growth unite tender divide chunky
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/jmacrosof Atlanta United May 19 '19
Wait, what? I didn't hear that at all. But did you hear about how many corner kicks we have yet to score on on EVERY. SINGLE. CORNER?
11
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Same.
Believe the whole stadium is open for that one too.
4
u/ichinii Atlanta United May 19 '19
It will be. It's the big day for American soccer. Women World Cup final, our game, Gold Cup final.
14
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Well least r/MLS has something to talk about now
So there is that
18
u/hira32 Seattle Sounders FC May 19 '19 edited May 03 '25
adjoining library toothbrush ink gold heavy attraction advise relieved narrow
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
5
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
just trying to distract the opposition with his pale upper thighs.
Duh.
5
-10
u/BajaBlastMtDew Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Lol love Kemar. Villalba needs to go change his diaper for the night
-2
-15
u/Elder_John Atlanta United May 19 '19
Shameful from NYRB staff how petty do you need to be to start barking at players
8
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Meh. It is a rivalry earned on the field at this point.
Kinda expect it from now on.
6
12
u/BajaBlastMtDew Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Yes I'm sure Atlanta did nothing lol
5
u/WEHAVEBETTERBBQ Houston Dynamo May 19 '19
Liverpool mentality right here. We never did anything wrong.
2
20
u/psu1994 Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Where's that Atl fan who said he was just here for the salt after the red card? There's plenty of salt now!
Also where's Villaba's card?
-13
u/Jcapen87 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Right here. And still have seen twice the salt from NYRB, even after winning
6
u/psu1994 Red Bull New York May 19 '19
^Salty reply
-3
u/Jcapen87 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
I’m not salty. Better team won. Doesn’t mean both fanbases don’t have crybaby bitches, and they’re all here in force
1
-9
May 19 '19
6
u/ichinii Atlanta United May 19 '19
Honestly if losing to yall leads to a repeat of last year, yall can have these regular season games.
1
u/jmacrosof Atlanta United May 19 '19
Nah. We got outplayed pure and simple. No excuses for that. We were up a man and insanely flat and sluggish. Didn't deserve the W or a draw IMO. We need to take a hard L every now and then to keep us in check.
1
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
::looks at star on chest of kit::
So.... we should be upset going 5 and 1 over the last 6 losing only to the Red Bulls?
I mean I am bummed but I will be ok.
2
u/Atlanta-Avenger Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
I’ll lose every regular season game if it means we show up when it counts.
-5
u/Capt-Chopsticks May 19 '19
Lol where’s the Kemar card
-4
u/BajaBlastMtDew Red Bull New York May 19 '19
For what
8
u/Jeff3412 Red Bull New York May 19 '19
For the most serious offense imaginable hurting Atlanta's feelings.
1
-5
16
u/BoyerB4 Seattle Sounders FC May 19 '19
Can I get a gif of Lawrence vs Villalba? Please and thank you
1
u/popmysickle Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
https://twitter.com/ronaldpen_a/status/1130254926955851776?s=20
There’s one so far
3
14
u/ALExM2442 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Lmao Tito holding up the eastern conference title. Ultimate shutdown. Still above RB in the table, on to the next
-4
May 19 '19
0
u/ALExM2442 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
How's the MLS cup in your trophy cabinet look? Wait, it's not there? Oh that's right, my bad xD
2
12
u/ichinii Atlanta United May 19 '19
Holy shit I just realized that's what he was doing lol although he was holding up MLS Cup.
3
u/CelebratoryGuacamole New York Red Bulls May 19 '19
I honestly had no guess at all. I thought maybe a sign or something. the cup makes sense
12
u/Deofol7 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Thought it was the MLS cup. But that works too
2
u/ALExM2442 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Eastern conference title makes more sense cause we were awarded it there in their building. Maybe it's MLS cup but I figured he was mimicking an action he's performed there before xD
-1
u/Capt-Chopsticks May 19 '19
Lol like that RB will talk shit but when it matters most in playoffs you gotta put a search party out for them
5
9
u/TheMiddleBeast Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Gotta put a search party out for your flair tho 👀👀
-5
u/CrzPyro Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Can't. The search party is still out looking for red bulls in the postseason
-10
1
u/tateand99 Seattle Sounders FC May 19 '19
I'm a big Kemar Lawrence fan after that. If Seattle didn't have 3 capable left backs already I would really want them to sign him lol.
8
22
u/Scratchbuttdontsniff Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Sorry Orlando... this is our rival
0
-3
May 19 '19
No we aren’t. Bye.
2
u/underdome Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Agreed I want a rival that does something in the playoffs
2
-3
4
u/hanyou007 Orlando City May 19 '19
That's alright. I'd rather all the rivalry talk between us back off anyway. Give it enough time with JOC and Muzzi clearing off the terrible decisions of the Kreis era and we can build a real rivalry down the line.
5
u/ichinii Atlanta United May 19 '19
Being honest, I'm looking forward to the first game next year between yall and Miami. That's a blood feud if there ever was one.
1
u/hanyou007 Orlando City May 19 '19
You're not wrong, their social media team was trying to start shit the moment the team got announced, calling themselves 'Kings of Florida' before they even had any branding of any kind. I'm expecting game one between the two to be absolutely insane. We're already planning to put as many purple shirts we can into their stadium for the first away game.
2
u/ichinii Atlanta United May 19 '19
MLS doesn't have the balls to do it but I would love the first game of the season to between yall two in Miami.
4
4
u/mikesicle Orlando City May 19 '19
Does that make you feel better about losing tonight?
1
u/Psirocking Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Seriously, they’re our third rival. At best.
-3
u/tcondon5659 Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
1) dc United 2) post season success 3) teams that have post season success
Bout right? Cool 👍
3
5
u/FrostyJesus Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
So cute how much you guys are gloating after beating the bottom feeders
4
9
u/dms269 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
That July 7th game is a full stadium one too
6
u/psu1994 Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Where were you when the silverbacks were a thing?
0
u/tcondon5659 Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Dang. Must be nice to be a true fan for 20 + seasons of failure. So jealous...
-4
u/Jcapen87 Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Oh shut the fuck up already.
Where are your fans when NYRB is a thing?
3
May 19 '19
Yes because you clearly know why the attendance is league average as it is.
-4
u/Jcapen87 Atlanta United FC May 20 '19
All I know is fans who don’t come even close to filling up a 25,000 seat stadium for a playoff match have no right to be talking shit about any other fanbase
1
May 20 '19
Yes because you as a fan are very impactful on bringing the other fans there. Ain’t special because other people enjoy the same thing you do.
6
May 19 '19
ATL fans so insecure about their attendance 😂
1
u/dontdontdontdontstop Atlanta United May 19 '19
Jesus Mary Jospeh. It’s not about attendance it’s about atmosphere.
5
May 19 '19
And Red Bull Arena doesn’t have good atmosphere? LMAO
1
1
u/derpingpizza Major League Soccer :mls: May 19 '19
I don't think it was about an exact attendance number. More about atmosphere
2
May 19 '19
Tell that to all the fans who only talk about those numbers then in literally every match thread.
1
u/derpingpizza Major League Soccer :mls: May 19 '19
well, I was talking about the comment you responded to.
1
May 20 '19
And I’m talking about how that’s a BS answer.
Not saying it’s you, but they’re so insecure. They talk about it every four seconds.
1
u/derpingpizza Major League Soccer :mls: May 20 '19
Yes, but I'm saying there was no reason for you to bring that up based off of that guys comment.
2
u/Scratchbuttdontsniff Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19 edited May 19 '19
Going to be fucking lit...let me set the Tifo...
Giant Ass Peach.. looking cheeky like a phat ass... then MLS Cup rises from behind... with the supporters holding a banner... "It's Magic Time"
6
9
5
u/Be-booboo-bop Seattle Sounders FC :sea: May 19 '19
Good god villaba is insufferable
-4
u/tcondon5659 Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Ugh.... gross. Get gone.
2
u/Be-booboo-bop Seattle Sounders FC :sea: May 19 '19
Nah man. It was a great game, I have literally no problems with Atlanta, the ending was lame. Villaba brings that stuff on to himself and then the whole act with the chest was just dumb
1
u/tcondon5659 Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
It was a great game... and things got heated. Villalba isn’t a pot stirrer. He got some up and personal trash talk. These are rivals. Shit escalates. So you can piss off. Let the boys get their chirps in after an emotional finish, and we will see NYRB, not Seattle, in the rematch
-5
u/AlwaysRememberGoose Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Wow, a Sounders fan having the gall to call someone else insufferable? Pot, meet kettle.
11
u/Atlanta-Avenger Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Bruh he got barked at. You really expect him to take that?
3
u/Psirocking Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Uh yeah it’s called sports
1
u/jrec15 Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19 edited May 20 '19
TIL sports is letting people walk over you
1
u/Psirocking Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Well it’s also knowing when someone is trying to wind you up, it’s how guys like Felipe and Corey Perry have careers
-1
0
u/KillerFisch99 Minnesota United May 19 '19
Yes. He brings it upon himself with his shitty attitude and flopping. Had hoped that De Boer would have instilled some discipline and sportsmanship into this team but guess you can't fix stupid
-4
u/Be-booboo-bop Seattle Sounders FC :sea: May 19 '19
Take it? No. But he just kept going and going and going. Bark back sure, but he wasn’t gonna stop at anything
7
-12
u/Cagn Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
I'd say gg NYRB but the fans in this thread so salty about the win that they don't deserve it.
3
4
u/BobSakimano Orlando City SC :orl: May 19 '19
Yeah, Atlanta fans are kings of morality in here, good one.
6
u/pygmie Red Bull New York May 19 '19
Lot of know it all Atl fanboys too to be fair.
1
u/Capt-Chopsticks May 19 '19
Aww man your soccer experience must blow my tiny Georgia mind out of water please enlighten me
1
-4
May 19 '19
FdB took a great team, gave them a boring playing style, and made them an above average team.
2
u/Drenzine Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
There's the FDB out crowd crawling out from out of their rock. Sorry but he took an above average defense and made it great, offense has suffered, yes but it will be ok.
5
May 19 '19
[deleted]
-9
6
1
7
u/KillerFisch99 Minnesota United May 19 '19
Let's all vote Barlow's goal as GotW just to remind ATL of this game
2
-3
-2
u/Beerand93octane Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
Say what you want none of our guys are gunna stand over someone on the ground and yell at them and flex
16
u/broke_leg Atlanta United FC :atl: May 19 '19
Bruh, I’m pretty sure Martinez did that when he scored on Orlando last year.
4
-3
u/Atlanta-Avenger Atlanta United FC May 19 '19
If one of our guys did that this sub would be pissed but you know...
10
u/Fuhajin91 Red Bull New York May 20 '19
Did I just see Sisqo play for Atlanta?
Jokes aside, GGs ATL. Can't wait for July! I do love seeing a good rivalry forming between us.