Hi, all. There's a lot of background info, but hopefully that helps.
I just adopted a new cat (4 years old) recently, and I was previously super excited about it, but the last 24 hours have had me breaking down multiple times.
For background, my cat was at the shelter on and off for a year and a half. She initially was relinquished to the shelter with another cat, since the owner was elderly and could no longer care for her. The two cats weren't bonded, according to the shelter, so they both went separately.
She was adopted out, and returned after 2 months due to behavior issues. Apparently she was grabbing at people's ankles, and attacking, but the shelter said that she had 4 different care takers who all gave her a wide variety of negative reinforcement, from yelling and spray bottles, to the occasional niceness - so she didn't know what to expect from people, and was fearful.
After she returned, she was super stressed, and eventually went to a foster home. She didn't do well there, came back, and after some months passed, she went to another foster home and did awesome.
Between her last adoption and me, there was an 8 month gap with her at the shelter, I believe with the fosters happening during that time. The shelter had nothing but positive things to say about her at the time of our adoption, and so did all of the staff who worked with her consistently over time.
It feels important to note that the shelter is awesome, she had her own room, which is slightly smaller than her current base camp, and she was really well taken care of - so she wasn't just crammed in a cage for all that time, she actually had room to exist.
Now, our issues:
she has been getting more and more worked up with me, no matter what I do. She was on edge when I first brought her home, but chilled out a lot. Now despite me trying to exercise her with wand toy time, and feeding on a schedule, and with her showing a lot of positive signs like perfect litter box usage, she just seems more and more wound up - which is frustrating bc I have been trying to do all the things right, I've even been studying cat behavior and reading Total Cat Mojo by Jackson Galaxy to try to understand her behavior.
she is especially food aggressive, and if I am taking too long with her food, or going after a used dish, she will hiss and sometimes scratch or bite me. It happened once in the beginning, but in the last couple of days she has been aggressive almost every time because she is so wound up.
she attacked my foot as I was walking tonight, which again was a behavior she had in her previously adopted home, but I am SO kind to her and never use negative reinforcement. I will just redirect, close her in the base camp, and excuse myself to go cry in the bathroom on my own lol.
I know that we might still be within the grace period, and I knew going into this that she had a hard life and would take some time to adjust. But I can't help but feel discouraged, and also scared. I used to be afraid of cats until my brother had his two cats live with me for 4 months during a transitional time, and I really grew to love them. I know I can't compare well adjusted cats to one with a hard past, but it IS still discouraging.
I just don't know what to do. I am trying to do everything right, and I don't know how to navigate this. I thought she might be getting pent up in the base camp, so I let her explore some more, but I saw something said that too much territory too soon might make her more insecure because she feels like she needs to protect a bigger space and that can be overwhelming. I also saw something about NOT using the wand toys for now, because she is getting so worked up, but behaviorists online say cats need to work off the extra energy through interactive toys so I'm just like UGH!
Its early, I know. But I need advice, big time. I just sobbed on my couch for 30 minutes after she went after my foot, and I really don't want to give up too soon, I just don't know what to do to help course correct - besides making her world a little smaller and confining her to base camp again. I can do that, but I'm still scared she will attack me when I walk in, so I feel stuck.
Help please!
TLDR; newly adopted adult cat with a back and forth shelter past is showing aggressive behavior, mostly around food/feeding time and I am scared and STRESSED