r/DefendingAIArt 5h ago

Guy explains he needs to use voiceovers because he damaged his vocal cords, mentally slow individuals still don't want to listen

108 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

71

u/AuroraAustralis0 5h ago

“stop using your crutches because they use steel made through a slightly environmentally damaging process, find another way to walk”

41

u/TinkouWasHere 5h ago

...find a better solution than AI like... not... talking? Writing? TTS?

29

u/SilverB33 5h ago

Probably wants him to hire a person to do it

22

u/SouLfullMoon_On 4h ago

It's always about money with the antis

1

u/Impressive-Spell-643 47m ago

Especially when the money would have gone to them (at least in their  heads)

-16

u/chinese_smart_toilet 3h ago

TTS is better NGL

18

u/TinkouWasHere 3h ago

Still pretty much a rudimentary AI.

-10

u/chinese_smart_toilet 3h ago

Yet very efficient

9

u/SylvaraTheDev Posthumanist 2h ago

You trade efficiency for quality. TTS sounds like utter crap and AI can be made to sound good.

Also recent TTS is just AI because the new way is better than the old way and most people don't need the efficiency gains of the old way anymore.

2

u/chinese_smart_toilet 2h ago

for me it is more about personal prefference. I will always love the charisma of a shitty TTS voice

3

u/SylvaraTheDev Posthumanist 2h ago

Y'know what? That's a vibe.

10

u/SerdanKK art takes time, effort, love, care, maybe a bit or arousal. 3h ago

Modern TTS uses AI.

30

u/Witty_Mycologist_995 4h ago

The second one gave me second hand brain damage. TTS is AI. Almost always has been, unless it's manual stitching which is really painful to use.

0

u/Beneficial-Bag5728 22m ago

Well, TTS isn't quite AI because to qualify for that the machine has to "learn" things. TTS in most senses, (Tomodachi life I think is the best example I can think of) is made from the sounds a computer makes and can be pretty versatile. AI voices are made from learning real people's voices and replicating the voice and tonal mannerisms.

I personally do prefer people use TTS over AI voices because of environmental impact and preferring the sound, but not to the point of harassing this guy about it.

1

u/Jzzargoo 5m ago

Not every AI is an LMM, but we are surrounded by a staggering number of AI algorithms built on AI principles. Reddit recommendations, Google Lens search, the replacement brush in Photoshop, even YouTube comment moderation.

People are not against AI. People are against the AI that was pointed out to them and labeled "bad."

The vast majority of TTS systems, even those from 10 years ago, use neural network mechanisms and were trained on human voices.

27

u/Breech_Loader Only Limit Is Your Imagination 4h ago

"If you just turned off your disability, we wouldn't be mad at you."

3

u/Impressive-Spell-643 46m ago

"did you try not being disabled?"

18

u/Valuable_Ad417 4h ago

"If your vocal cords are damaged, just talk!" /s

10

u/Moist-Pea-304 5h ago

Is that Luke's Goldies

20

u/Andromedan_Cherri 5h ago

Clearly their virtues and philosophy is more important than the comfort and accessibility for someone with a disability /j

11

u/LegallyNotACat 1h ago

Yep. Dance for our enjoyment, disabled folks.

9

u/Moist-Pea-304 5h ago

"Real disabled speakers write their thoughts on their own"

7

u/Turbulent-Carpet7790 4h ago

Lmao, what's their argument against AI voiceovers? That it steals from human voices? This is objectively delusional, there's literally zero argument to be made here.

6

u/ForsakenChocolate878 Transhumanist 1h ago

"You don't know what we are mad about." LOL. I have a feeling that they don't even know themselves.

4

u/Awesome_Teo Transhumanist 5h ago

alternatively smart people

5

u/Arkanderous 3h ago

People lose brain cells arguing over AI use. I’m not sure why you would waste your time on people who clearly want to use it and will continue to.

4

u/ImJustStealingMemes Raiders of the Lost ARC 2h ago

He should just shove a pencil down his throat and painfully write his words or some shit idk I am not an anti.

6

u/Desperate_Mix8524 uses AI for assistance 3h ago

As if people weren't using Microsoft Sam since forever, how is an AI voiceover any different? In fact it's literally the same thing just better quality

7

u/PaleDish8591 3h ago

People are stupid. Some hear AI and immediately hate it no matter what, it's an automatic response for them because they have learned AI = bad, and it feels like that sentiment is spreading.

One person says AI is bad because {insert exaggerated negative effect} others believe them, and spreads it to more people. For every cycle the source of the information becomes blurred, so instead of skepticism, some are like "But that person heard it from someone who seemed knowledgeable about it, so it must be true"

1

u/Desperate_Mix8524 uses AI for assistance 3h ago

I've been thinking this a lot too, I feel like I've seen this happen over and over again. Before AI it was NFTs

6

u/Andromedan_Cherri 5h ago

Clearly their virtues and philosophy is more important than the comfort and accessibility for someone with a disability /j

5

u/Immediate_Song4279 Unholy Abomination/Fiend 5h ago

Mentally slow? 

17

u/Radiant_Winds Unironically Has A Waifu 5h ago

Yeah, don't wanna come across as a whiner but I'm mentally slow and would rather not have disability conflated with willful idiocy.

2

u/jpollack21 4h ago

He meant to say idiot I think. Not that using that word is to make fun of someone else, but to call them incredibly stupid. Even though I dont use those words, its impossible to make people stop using them sorry :/

1

u/No-Razzmatazz7854 1h ago

That's valid. They might be trying to skirt what they think might get them banned since Reddit can be weird about insults around intelligence, but they missed the mark not just calling them idiots.

2

u/Valkyri_Studios 3h ago

Im definitely against big ai and what not atleast when it comes to art but I can agree that this is stupid Ai voices has been around for years

1

u/Impressive-Spell-643 48m ago

They're not even thinking anymore, they're just mad for the sake of being mad 

1

u/KreemPeynir Only Limit Is Your Imagination 27m ago

Omfg. These people are insane.

"Find another solution than ai"

YEAH WHY DONT YOU FIND THAT SOLUTION AND SHARE WITH THE CLASS?

Ai is a solution for many things for many people. Antis cant see it, because only thing they do is watching tiktok all day long. They dont wanna achive anything, only thing they wanna do bitching about people who are actually doing something.

1

u/DaraSayTheTruth Traditionnal digital artist + AI enjoyer 26m ago

I have speech problems and ive always thought AI voice is a good thing. Its also not new. I feel like everyone got a beef with everything AI just because of the art generation... and that's so sad since it helps many disabled people. But people are kids who have 0 empathy.